Romance Editing
with Clara Carlson-Kirigin
Professional editing can help you create and publish a compelling romance your readers will love. With the diverse editorial skillset I’ve been developing since 2018 and extensive market research in the romance genre, I can help you strengthen your story, polish your writing, and find success on your chosen publishing path.
Editing a romance novel by yourself is hard!
Maybe your manuscript isn’t where you want it to be, but you don’t know how to fix it.
Or the idea of publishing your novel feels overwhelming, and you don’t know where to start.
Whether your dream is to . . .
Complete and publish your debut novel
See your novel in bookstores
Give your readers a story they can’t put down
Create an income doing what you love
. . . you can rely on my knowledge and experience as a romance editor to help you get there.
My romance editing services can help you…
Save Money
Know you’re getting the most cost-effective type of editing for your manuscript and your budget
Save Time
Make your revision time more efficient and effective, focusing on what actually needs your attention
Save Stress
Experience less stress and overwhelm as you confidently navigate the publishing process
My Process for Editing Romance Novels
I believe in actionable advice, presented in a way that celebrates your strengths and gets you motivated for the revision process.
My process as a romance editor has 3 steps:
Step 1: Planning
Before we commit to working together, we discuss your vision for the story, check that we’re a good fit, and confirm what type of editing will be most beneficial for you.
Step 2: Your Romance Edit(s)
I edit your romance novel, providing actionable advice to improve the manuscript while staying true to your vision and helping you provide the best experience for your readers.
Step 3: Query or Blurb Editing
With 3 rounds of editing, we polish your query or blurb to help it sell your story either to romance readers or to agents and publishers, depending on your chosen publishing path.
One of the hardest parts of finding an editor was finding someone who understood my writing style and knew how to strengthen it. I sent samples to many editors over several projects, and it wasn’t until I received a sample back from Clara at Prometheus Editorial that I knew she was the one for me!
She knows how to edit my work while also keeping my word choice. When she finds something that might change the way my story is written, she asks questions and communicates options with grammatical rules, giving me the choice to make the changes that work best for my story. I plan on having Clara edit all my future novels, since I love working with her!
~Dee Rollings, Contemporary Romance Author of A Liar and a Thief
Types of Romance Editing
Most of the editing I do falls into one of the following categories:
Copyediting
An in-depth edit with redlining and comments in the manuscript document to improve the writing and keep readers engaged
Developmental Editing
An in-depth edit with scene-level comments and broad big-picture feedback to improve the story and captivate readers
Editorial Assessment
A big-picture edit that pinpoints the most significant story issues and recommends solutions to make the story more compelling
Romance Editing for Your Vision, Your Voice, & Your Readers
Good communication is integral to the author-editor relationship. When I understand your vision, I can give you the best advice for your story. And when you understand my feedback, you can focus your revisions on making your romance as engaging as possible for your readers. With that goal, I will make sure you have opportunities to ask for clarification and run additional ideas by me as you navigate your revisions.
Your Vision
You are the expert on your story. I offer suggestions based on my knowledge of language, storytelling, and the current market for romance novels, but you get to decide what will bring your story closer to your vision.
Your Voice
Your voice is what makes your stories unique and a big part of why your readers love them. I can help you polish your writing and bring out your voice, but I would never try to change it or make you sound less like yourself.
Your Readers
You know your readers best. I help you improve their experience based on my knowledge of romance readers in general, but you get to decide who you’re writing for and which of my suggestions serve them best.
Your Choices
My editing style is to provide guidance while encouraging you to trust your intuition. Once I give you the information you need, you will be able to decide what’s best for your vision of the story, your voice, and your readers.
I view editing as a teaching process. I don’t just want to tell you how to make your current manuscript better. I want to help you grow as a writer, improving your skill with writing and storytelling so that you can delight readers with your ability to make each novel better than the last.
Copyediting for Romance
You may be looking for a romance editor to polish your writing and help you convey your story clearly and effectively to your readers.
This is usually a copyedit, which can get you:
Clarity
Excellent grammar, spelling, and punctuation
Polish
Polished writing that helps your voice stand out
Impact
Phrasing and word choice that captivates readers
Quality
A high-quality novel that readers will love
Developmental Editing for Romance
Or you might want a romance editor to focus on the story and the big picture and help each scene drive the story forward.
This usually means a developmental edit, which helps you with your:
Characters
Compelling characters readers want to root for
Structure
A strong romance arc that drives your story forward
Setting
A setting readers get to experience vividly
Story
An engaging story your readers will love
Editorial Assessment for Romance
If you aren’t sure what your manuscript needs, can only afford a smaller edit, or want to include multiple rounds of editing to get your manuscript as good as it can be, you may want to start with an editorial assessment.
This includes the same type of story editing as a developmental edit but goes into less depth. It focuses on the big picture rather than including feedback on each scene or in-line comments in the manuscript document. With years of experience as a romance novel editor, I can quickly identify the main issues in your story and show you what needs your focus.
Clara carefully reads to gain an understanding of both you and what you’re trying to say. Her developmental editing advice is respectful, knowledgeable, and on point. She’s smart, well-versed in her craft, and takes her responsibility seriously. She will give you value and treat you honestly.
Her copy and line editing reflect the same qualities, and regardless of what type of editing you choose, she will offer advice on other matters for which she has no obligation – to make your writing better.
That is my experience, and I would not hesitate for a New York minute, to recommend Clara if you are a serious writer.
~Robert Every, Romance Author of A Day Like Any Other
Publishing Guidance from a Romance Editor
While I can’t guarantee you a publishing deal or a certain level of book sales, I want help you give your book its best chance at success. This is why I offer more than just manuscript editing.
I can help you choose which publishing path is right for you, and share my industry knowledge to help your book succeed.
For every romance novel I edit, I include either query letter and synopsis editing (for romance authors on the traditional publishing path) or blurb editing and keyword research (for self-publishing romance authors) at no cost. This editing is done in three rounds: developmental editing to make sure each important point is covered, line editing to improve clarity and impact, and copyediting to fix distracting errors.
Many authors don’t know how beneficial these services can be, and they can get expensive when you get them done separately. I don’t want you to have to choose between spending extra money or skipping a step that could make a big difference in getting your novel in front of the people who want to read it.
Romance Editing for Authors Planning to Query
If you are on a traditional publishing path and choose to work with me, you’ll get to:
Revise your manuscript based on what agents and publishers are looking for
Navigate the querying process with less frustration and overwhelm
Make a great first impression with an excellent query letter
Sell your story to agents and publishers with a polished synopsis
Romance Editing for Self-Publishers
If you are on a self-publishing path and choose to work with me, you’ll get to:
Revise your manuscript based on what romance readers are looking for
Navigate the world of self-publishing with more confidence and less stress
Sell your story to your target readers with a high-quality blurb
Use optimized keywords to help the right people find your novel
Sample Edits & Free Consultations
To give you an idea of my editing style before we commit to working together, I offer a short sample edit or a 30-minute phone/Zoom consultation to new clients. This will give you an idea of my editing approach and whether it works for you.
I like to briefly review the manuscript beforehand, at least the first chapter or two but ideally the full manuscript. You deserve an editor who’s a great fit for your novel, so I like to make sure ahead of time that I’m the right person for your story and your writing style.
Seeing the full manuscript also helps me get a sense of how much work is needed so that I can provide an accurate quote.
For copyediting, a sample edit is the best way for you to get a sense of my editing style. This will include editorial suggestions in redlining as well as comments alongside the manuscript.
I’ve found that a phone or Zoom consultation is a better approach for developmental editing and editorial assessments. This will help us get on the same page about your vision for the story and give you an idea of how I approach story editing.
Scheduling Your Romance Edit
If you’re expecting to need editing within the next few months, now is the time to reach out! Sometimes my schedule fills up quickly, so it’s better to ask about my availability now than wait too long and end up with delays.
Romance Editing Costs
The prices below reflect common ranges for each of my romance editing services. Every edit is different, and the cost is based on the scope of the edit and how much work is needed, so these are just broad estimates that most romance manuscripts fall into.
Whichever type(s) of edit you choose, your novel will also get free query letter and synopsis editing or free blurb editing and keyword research once you’re ready to move forward with publishing.
Copyediting
Focus on writing and mechanics- Redlining and comments alongside the manuscript to help you communicate clearly with your readers
- Sentence-level suggestions to help your writing flow and make it more engaging and impactful
- Identifying and resolving errors based on the guidelines of The Chicago Manual of Style
- Ensuring consistency with a style sheet that tracks spelling, capitalization, and punctuation choices
- Occasional feedback on story inconsistencies and internal contradictions
- A great choice for manuscripts that have already resolved any big-picture issues
Developmental Editing
In-depth focus on the story- Comments alongside the manuscript for scene-level improvements to help each scene drive the story forward
- A separate revision letter with big-picture feedback on the story as a whole
- Feedback on the plot and story structure, including the key scenes that make up your story arc
- Feedback on character development and character arcs, as well as point of view and perspective
- Feedback on the setting and worldbuilding and how well they immerse readers in the story world
- Feedback on how the story meets the expectations of your genre and its readers
Editorial Assessment
Big-picture focus on the story- All feedback is presented in a separate revision letter that provides big-picture feedback on the story as a whole
- Occasional feedback on specific scenes or sections of the story that require special attention
- Feedback on the plot and story structure, including the key scenes that make up your story arc
- Feedback on character development and character arcs, as well as point of view and perspective
- Feedback on the setting and worldbuilding and how well they immerse readers in the story world
- Feedback on how the story meets the expectations of your genre and its readers
Clara Carlson-Kirigin
Fantasy & Romance Editor
I spend most of my time editing various subgenres of fantasy and romance, with the occasional literary fiction novel thrown in, and some legal transcripts for variety.
I have a bachelor's degree from Oberlin College where I majored in Latin, minored in History and Ancient Greek, and at one point taught a 1-credit course on The Silmarillion and J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle-earth. In addition to Tolkien, some of my favorite authors include Tamsyn Muir, George R.R. Martin, and Tamora Pierce.
If you want help turning your manuscript into a compelling story your readers won't be able to put down, I would love to hear from you!
Prometheus: The Greek Titan of forethought and innovation who brought humankind the gift of fire, leading to the development of art and civilization. Credited by the playwright Aeschylus with the invention of writing. [from the Greek προμηθεια (prometheia) FORESIGHT; πρό prep, BEFORE; μαθεῖν vb (aor, act, inf of μανθάνω), LEARN]